When tackling a project as audacious,
slippery and fraught with diagnostic peril as “the 10 best rock bands ever,”
one can either cower in anticipation of the monsoon of disagreement
sure to come and load the package with every manner of weaselly
equivocation, or one can swagger ahead blissfully secure in the
universal righteousness of one’s judgment. Being American, I choose the
latter.
1. The Beatles
The Beatles are unquestionably the best and most
important band in rock history, as well as the most compelling story.
Almost miraculously, they embodied the apex of the form artistically,
commercially, culturally and spiritually at just the right time, the
tumultuous '60s, when music had the power to literally change the world
(or at least to give the impression that it could, which may be the
same thing). The Beatles are the archetype: there is no term in the
language analogous to “Beatlemania.”
Three lads from Liverpool — John Lennon,
Paul McCartney and George Harrison — came together at a time of great
cultural fluidity in 1960 (with bit players Stu Sutcliffe and Pete
Best), absorbed and recapitulated American rock ‘n’ roll and British
pop history unto that point, hardened into a razor sharp unit playing
five amphetamine-fueled sets a night in the tough port town of Hamburg,
Germany, returned to Liverpool, found their ideal manager in Brian
Epstein and ideal producer in George Martin, added the final piece of
the puzzle when Ringo Starr replaced Best on drums, and released their
first single in the U.K., “Love Me Do/P.S. I Love You,” all by October
of 1962.
Their second single, “Please Please Me,”
followed by British chart-toppers “From Me to You,” “She Loves You,” “I
Want to Hold Your Hand,” “Can’t Buy Me Love” (all Lennon/McCartney
originals), and the group’s pleasing image, wit and charm, solidified
the Fab Four’s delirious grip on their homeland in 1963.
But it was when the group arrived in the
U.S. in February 1964 that the full extent of Beatlemania became
manifest. Their pandemonium-inducing five-song performance on the Ed
Sullivan Show on February 9 is one of the cornerstone mass media events
of the 20th century. I was five at the time — my parents
tell me I watched it with them, but I honestly don’t remember. I do
remember, though, that the girls next door, four and six years older
than I, flipped over that appearance and dragged me into their giddy
madness soon thereafter. I loved “I Want to Hold Your Hand,” the
Beatles’ first No. 1 in the U.S. (they had 19 more, still the record),
more than any other song I have ever heard, or almost assuredly will
ever hear, with a consuming intensity that I can only now touch as a
memory.
The Beatles generated an intensity of
joy that slapped tens of millions of people in the face with the
awareness that happiness and exuberance were not only possible, but in
their presence, inevitable. They generated an energy that was amplified
a million times over and returned to them in a deafening tidal wave of
grateful hysteria.
A partial result of that deafening
hysteria was that the band became frustrated with their concerts and
stopped performing live after a San Francisco show on August 29, 1966.
Yet even this frustration bore fruit, as the four musicians, aided
almost incalculably by producer Martin, turned their creative energies
to the recording studio, producing ever more sophisticated and
accomplished albums “Rubber Soul” (1965, “Drive My Car,” “Norwegian
Wood,” “You Won’t See Me,” “Nowhere Man,” “Michelle”), “Revolver”
(1966, Harrison’s “Taxman,” “Eleanor Rigby,” “Here, There and
Everywhere,” “Yellow Submarine,” “Good Day Sunshine,” “And Your Bird
Can Sing”), the majestic and epochal “Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club
Band” (1967, title track, “With a Little Help From My Friends,” “Lucy
In the Sky With Diamonds,” “When I’m Sixty-Four,” “A Day In the Life”).
Though centrifugal force began to take
its toll, they still managed to produce three more album masterpieces,
double-album “The Beatles” (1968, a.k.a. “The White Album,” with “Back
In the USSR,” “Dear Prudence,” “Ob-La-Di Ob-La-Da,” Harrison’s “While
My Guitar Gently Weeps,” “Blackbird,” “Birthday,” “Helter Skelter”),
“Let It Be” (recorded in early 1969 but not released until 1970, with
the title track, “Two Of Us,” “Across the Universe,” “I’ve Got a
Feeling,” “The Long and Winding Road” and “Get Back”), and the fitting
climax “Abbey Road” (1969, Harrison’s “Here Comes the Sun” and
“Something,” Ringo’s “Octopus’s Garden,” “Come Together,” “Maxwell’s
Silver Hammer,” “I Want You,” “She Came In Through the Bathroom
Window”).
They made an incredible promise and
instead of backing down from that promise they delivered and delivered
and delivered for eight years until the full implications of the
promise finally hit them: they were staring into the jaws of an
insatiable, ravenous beast that was no less beastly because it smiled
and waved and gave them money. The Beatles finally suffered a
collective inability to pretend that the beast was not a beast, and in
1970 they broke up and returned to being human.
Beatlemania redux
A small but significant slice of the Beatles’ magic
came back in 1986 with release of the classic John Hughes teen flick
“Ferris Bueller’s Day Off,” wherein Matthew Broderick’s title character
lip-syncs the early Beatles classic “Twist and Shout” (ironically, a
song they didn’t write) from the top of a float in a downtown Chicago
parade.
John Lennon sang “Twist and Shout” as
though the words were joyful corrosive poison, that his only hope of
survival was to expel them with all the vehemence that his
rhythm-besotted body could muster, and so does Ferris in the scene.
Paul and George’s responses matched John’s zeal at the end of each
stanza with their delirious “Ooohs.” They were enjoying themselves so
much that this song seemed the most important thing in their lives at
that moment. The Beatles knew the awesome responsibilities of pleasure.
Ferris lips lustily, the frauleins on
the float shimmy and shake and bounce off of Ferris like electrons, the
thousands in the crowd sing along from the pits of their pelvises.
Chicago jams as one, recreating the Beatles’ amazing real-life feat of
a unifying mass-madness that changed people’s lives for a time.
When I saw the movie in the theater in
‘86, people actually stood up and danced in the aisles. How could they
not? The “Twist and Shout” segment was the most exciting and joyous
musical moment in a movie since the Beatles own “A Hard Day’s Night”
(1964), and was the perfect climax to Ferris Bueller’s film exploits.
The public was so wistful for
Beatlemania that “Twist and Shout” returned to the charts for 15 weeks
that year, a brief but sweet reminder of the real thing.
2. The Rolling Stones
When the Beatles ceased to exist in 1970, the title
of “World’s Greatest Rock ‘n’ Roll Band” fell with very little dispute
to the Rolling Stones, who by then were in the middle of such a
wondrous creative peak that they might have challenged the Fab Four for
the title anyway. It’s a title the one-time “anti-Beatles” haven’t
relinquished since. Not only have the Stones been the greatest rock
band in the world for more than 30 years, but they have been a
functioning rock ‘n’ roll unit for more than 40, the longest run in
history.
Boyhood friends Mick Jagger and Keith
Richards, along with guitarist Brian Jones and pianist Ian Stewart,
formed the first version of the Rollin’ Stones in 1962, and with the
crack rhythm section of Charlie Watts on drums and Bill Wyman on bass
soon on board, were ripping it up in an eight-month residency at
London’s Crawdaddy Club shortly thereafter. A young and ambitious
Andrew Loog Oldham saw them there:
“I saw them April 23, 1963 and then I
knew what I had been training for,” he said in a phone interview from
his home in Colombia. “The main thing they had was passion, which has
served them to this day,” Oldham continued. Oldham’s first act as
manager was to demote the shambling Stewart from the band’s live act
for not keeping with his image of a lean, mean and sexy Stones (Stewart
was the band’s road manager and recorded with them until his death in
1985).
At the time the Rollin’ Stones (named
for the Muddy Waters song, Oldham added the “g”) were a ragged R&B
cover band, but their run at the Crawdaddy had generated much
attention, and with the Beatles on their way up no one wanted to miss
the next big thing. Oldham quickly got them signed to Decca Records,
which was still smarting from having turned down the Beatles.
In June of '63 the Stones’ first single,
a cover of Chuck Berry’s “Come On” went to No. 21 in the UK. The
follow-up in November was a cover of the dreaded Beatles’ “I Wanna Be
Your Man,” which rose to UK No. 12. By February of '64, they reached
the UK Top 10 with Buddy Holly’s “Not Fade Away,” which also cracked
the Top 50 in the U.S. — the bad boys were on their way.
 |
|
Yui Mok / AP
Despite their advancing age, Mick
Jagger, left, and Keith Richards and their band, the Rolling Stones,
are a better band live now than they were in the 1970s.
|
Oldham split with the band amid the insanity and media frenzy of drug
busts in 1967, but he and the band generated some amazing music during
the two years between the squirmingly lascivious “Satisfaction” —
considered by many the greatest rock song ever — released in May 1965,
and the hit-filled “Flowers” compilation, released in July '67.
Included was the incredibly self-aware narcissism of “Get Off Of My
Cloud,” chamber music gentility and vulnerability of “As Tears Go By,”
bemused urban modernity of “19
th Nervous Breakdown”; and the
Stones’ first classic album, “Aftermath,” with the simultaneously
mocking and empathetic drug song “Mother’s Little Helper,” deeply
groovy and misogynistic “Under My Thumb” and “Out Of Time,” lovely
“Lady Jane,” and exotic, roiling “Paint It Black.”
Then came the Stones classic
late-'60s/early-'70s period between “Beggar’s Banquet” and “Exile On
Main Street,” possibly the most productive run in rock history, when
the Stones turned an unequaled alchemy of rock ‘n’ roll, blues and
country into something dark, dangerous and enduringly deep.
The 1967 busts seemed to spur Jagger and
Richards to another creative level, but Brian Jones appeared beaten and
sinking fast. He was absent from the devilish, riff-rocking “Jumping
Jack Flash” single. He barely worked on 1968’s exceptional, bluesy
“Beggar’s Banquet” (seductive, percussive and stinging “Sympathy For
the Devil,” guitar-pounding “Street Fighting Man,” slashing and sinful
“Stray Cat Blues”), was out of the group by June '69, and dead at the
bottom of his swimming pool less than a month later.
Young Mick Taylor joined as Jones’s
replacement, and his hefty bluesy leads were the perfect foil for
Richards’ open-tuned rhythm work, and the sound and imagery grew darker
and harder still on “Let it Bleed” (the sex and death apocalypse “Gimme
Shelter,” Robert Johnson’s anguished blues “Love In Vain,” mysterious
“Monkey Man,” the druggy camaraderie of the title track, powerful and
murderous "Midnight Rambler,” and the oblique, uplifting coda “You
Can’t Always Get What You Want”).
The band’s dance with the devil bore
bitter fruit when they put on a free concert at Altamont Speedway
outside San Francisco on December 6, 1969 (just three months after
Woodstock) where a fan was stabbed to death in view of the stage by
Hell’s Angels (all the mounting bad juju was captured for posterity in
the film “Gimme Shelter”).
“Get Yer Ya-Ya’s Out” (1970), one of the
most satisfying live rock albums ever, focused on their '68-'69 hits,
including an extended, definitive “Midnight Rambler,” and showed how
integral Mick Taylor had become to the Stones’ roaring live sound.
The band’s first release on their own
Rolling Stones Records was the druggy, shambling, brilliant “Sticky
Fingers” (1971), with the infamous working-zipper cover by Andy Warhol.
Taylor again sparkled and the Jagger/Richards songwriting continued at
the highest level: swaggering “Brown Sugar,” plaintive “Wild Horses,”
jazzy grooving “Can’t You Hear Me Knocking,” horn-rocking “Bitch,”
chilling “Sister Morphine” and countrified “Dead Flowers.”
The murky, dense, jumbled double album “Exile on Main Street” closed
the era of Stones invincibility in 1972. A yeasty blend of all the
band’s roots influences — blues, country, soul, gospel and rock —
“Exile” yields fresh revelations more than 30 years later, and “Rocks
Off,” “Rip This Joint,” “Tumbling Dice,” “Sweet Virginia,” “Happy,”
“All Down the Line” and “Shine a Light” are among the band’s best work.
The Stones have been a different band
ever since: Mick Taylor left in 1974, replaced by the stalwart Ronnie
Wood. They have released a couple great albums: “Some Girls” (1978),
their rough response to the challenges of disco and punk (“Miss You,”
“Some Girls,” “Respectable,” “Beast of Burden,” “Shattered”), and
“Tattoo You” (1981, their top-charting album ever — nine weeks at No.
1) with standouts “Start Me Up,” “Hang Fire” and “Waiting On a Friend.”
They have also released a lot of simply good albums: the '70s were
better than the '80s, which were better than the '90s.
But they have soldiered on, taking
breaks but focusing more and more on getting the music out to the fans
live, becoming particularly reinvigorated with the “Steel Wheels” album
and world tour in 1989. I caught that tour in Los Angeles and the
Stones came on with an air of eager assurance. All of the elements
clicked: the guitars cut and slashed, the rhythm section locked in and
rode it out, the songs were a perfect blending of old and new, the band
was abundantly enthusiastic.
Jagger didn’t exhibit a drop of Cool
Star attitude: he worked, talked, sang with energy and attention to
detail. He was obviously happy to be liked again. The collective joyous
relief of the stadium buoyed Jagger to childlike vulnerability:
“Do ya like the new songs?” he almost
pleaded of the throng.
”We love them, Mick!”
”We love you!”
”Yeahh!”
Maybe Mick was reminded of his quote
from the '70s, “Sometimes I prefer being on stage, sometimes I prefer
orgasm.” That night, I’m pretty sure the stage won.
In the 1990s, the band took in a
staggering $750 million from three tours. When I watched them live from
Madison Square Garden on HBO early last year my eyes confirmed that
these craggy, gaunt guys are about 60 years old, but when the cameras
pulled back 30 years melted away and the magic was real and grew in
intensity as the night wore on.
What a great show! The Stones are a
better band live now than they were in the '70s when their lives,
bodies and minds were a quagmire of sex, drugs and alcohol. Age has
focused them, yet taken away very little of their maniacal energy, and
Keith Richards is still the greatest rhythm guitarist who ever lived.
Long live rock ‘n’ roll — long live the
Rolling Stones!
3. U2
Ireland’s U2 is the most important and influential
band of the post-punk era, joining ringing guitar rock, punkish
independence, Celtic spirituality, innovative production techniques and
electronic experimentalism — all held together by singer/lyricist
Bono’s transcendent vision and charisma.
U2 — Bono (Paul Hewson), guitarist the
Edge (Dave Evans), bassist Adam Clayton and drummer Larry Mullen —
formed in Dublin in 1976 as a Beatles and Stones cover band while the
players were all still in high school. In 1980 they were signed to
Island Records and released their spectacular first album, “Boy,”
produced by Steve Lillywhite.
 |
|
Mike Hutchings /
Reuters file
U2, with guitarist the Edge and lead
singer Bono, is now a mature, confident, still amazing band that
knows it doesn’t have all the answers, but isn’t afraid to keep asking
the right questions.
|
The band’s sparkling, radiant sound jumped from the grooves from the
first note of “I Will Follow” and rode Mullen’s massive drums and the
Edge’s angular, careening guitar into history. Neither “Boy” nor its
follow-up “October” (with the glorious “Gloria”) tore up the charts at
the time (though both are now platinum), but “War” — passionate,
martial “Sunday Bloody Sunday,” melodic wailing “New Year’s Day,” and
the fierce, new wavy love song “Two Hearts Beat As One”—turned U2 into
a worldwide phenomenon in 1983.
In preparation for 1984’s “The
Unforgettable Fire,” producer Brian Eno had a long conversation with
Bono, as he later told Q Magazine. “I said, ‘Look, if I work with you,
I will want to change lots of things you do, because I’m not interested
in records as a document of a rock band playing on stage, I’m more
interested in painting pictures. I want to create a landscape within
which this music happens.’ And Bono said, ‘Exactly, that’s what we want
too.’”
The results of this fateful change of
direction were Eno productions of U2 standards “The Unforgettable Fire”
(including “Bad,” “Pride In the Name of Love”); Grammy’s 1987 Album of
the Year, the personal yet universal “The Joshua Tree,” which made the
band superstars (with “Where the Streets Have No Name,” “I Still
Haven’t Found What I’m Looking For,” “With Or Without You” and “One
Tree Hill”); 1991's “Achtung Baby,” a brilliant and emotionally dark
move toward electronica (“Even Better Than the Real Thing,” “One,”
“Until the End of the World,” “Who’s Gonna Ride Your Wild Horses” and
“Mysterious Ways”); and “Zooropa,” deeper still into Euro-dance music
and electronics (‘93, with the title track, “Numb,” “Lemon,” “Stay”).
Wow, what a journey.
U2 was the leading rock band of the '80s
because its members, like perhaps only Bruce Springsteen in the U.S.,
still believed that rock ‘n’ roll could save the world, and they had
the talent to make that notion not seem hopelessly naive.
This earnestness and willingness to
shoulder the heaviest of responsibilities led to soaring heights of
achievement and escalating psychic and artistic demands that eventually
led the band to adopt irony as its basic means of expression for a time
in the '90s.
All bands want to be cool, and in the
'80s U2 almost single-handedly made earnestness cool, but it was hard,
relentless work. After the gritty, chunky guitars-and-idealism of the
'80s, the '90s saw the diaphanous chill of electronics-and-irony, which
was literally and metaphorically cool, but ultimately not what the band
is about.
“All That You Can’t Leave Behind” (‘00)
returned to what the band is about, and is the sonic and
spiritual follow up to the “The Joshua Tree,” the band’s most
idealistic, spiritual and melodically consistent album.
Remnants of the band’s forays into
electronics seasoned the album (especially the impressionistic “New
York”), but the Edge’s guitar returned to center stage where his
unique, chiming style belongs, though it never upstages the songs,
every one of which is blessed with a memorable tune.
Following the ecstatic release of the
opening track “Beautiful Day,” the second song “Stuck In a Moment You
Can’t Get Out Of,” states a seemingly modest but deeply profound,
earnest and idealistic notion:
“I’m just trying to find a decent
melody
A song I can sing in my own company”
They have found it and then some. U2 is
now a mature, confident, still amazing band that knows it doesn’t have
all the answers, but isn’t afraid to keep asking the right questions.
4. The Grateful Dead
Out on the road today/I saw a Deadhead sticker
on a Cadillac/A little voice inside my head/Said ‘don’t look back, you
can never look back.’ — Don Henley, “Boys of Summer”
When Henley wrote “The Boys of Summer’
in 1984, he saw the sticker on luxurious Detroit steel as a
contradiction of values: a symbolic matter/antimatter collision that
obliterated the meaning of both. But Henley didn’t realize that his
symbol of a Dead past was in reality a very powerful symbol of the
present and future.
The Vietnam War was the perfect
polarizer between youth and adult culture: it had no clear objective,
it was far away, it cost many lives, and it was involuntary — the old
made the decisions, the young died. After the war was mercifully killed
in the mid-'70s, the nation came to realize that it had hated the
internal confusion more than it had hated the external enemy — blood is
thicker than ideology.
 |
|
Toby Talbot / AP
The Grateful Deal, featuring the
late Jerry Garcia on guitar, carries on its musical and cultural
lineage to this day.
|
As a result, both sides of the internal conflict embraced the perceived
highlights of the other’s culture: adults lightened up — Johnny Carson
grew his hair long and joked with the band about smoking pot — and the
youth embraced the acquisitive materialism of their parents with the
shamelessness of Midas.
The Dead became the symbol of
this blending of ideologies until Jerry Garcia’s death in 1995: a
well-oiled money making machine ($50 million a year in concert revenue)
that sold peace, love and understanding to a legion of internally
divided admirers. The Dead sold out every show because a Dead show was
a socially acceptable place to temporarily take a break from the rat
race and try on '60s hippie values without having to live them. People
who didn’t do drugs any other time indulged and danced around like
pixies to the Dead and their light, rhythmic, pleasant, sometimes
inspired, extended musical journeys.
On that musical front, Rhino’s “Very
Best of the Grateful Dead” is an excellent representation of the band’s
eclectic blending of country, folk, psychedelic rock, R&B, jazz and
Afro-Caribbean rhythms on classics like “Friend of the Devil,” “Sugar
Magnolia,” “Ripple,” “Truckin’,” “Uncle John’s Band,” “Casey Jones,”
“Franklin’s Tower,” and their lone hit single “Touch of Grey.”
“Grateful Dead” (1971) is my favorite
live set by the band — it rolls along with “Bertha,” “Mama Tried,”
“Playing in the Band,” “Johnny B. Goode,” “Not Fade Away” and “Goin’
Down the Road Feeling Bad,” showing great energy and versatility.
The Dead’s success inspired the entire
jam band movement, which carries on its musical and cultural lineage to
this day.
5. Velvet Underground
Brian Eno has famously said that not many people
bought the Velvet’s albums when they were originally released, but
everyone who did formed a band. After bravely jousting the twin enemies
of indifference and open hostility in its lifetime, the Velvet
Underground has gradually been embraced as one of the best and most
important bands in rock history.
Recording a mere four studio albums and one live album in the
late-'60s, the group established an aesthetic so extreme, alien and
ahead of its time that it has taken three decades for the world to
catch up. The essence of that aesthetic is an unapologetic embrace of
the opposite poles of the musical, emotional and thematic spectrum:
naked power on the one end and exquisite beauty on the other, squalid
Saturday night nihilism followed by pristine Sunday morning reverence
conjured from the urban essence of New York.
The Velvet Underground formed in 1964
when singer/guitarist/songwriter Lou Reed and Welsh
multi-instrumentalist John Cale met and decided to form a rock band
(eventually with Sterling Morrison on bass and guitar and Maureen “Mo”
Tucker on percussion), drawing upon their mutual interest in R&B,
the free-form jazz of Albert Ayler and Ornette Coleman and the
avant-garde minimalism of John Cage and La Monte Young.
The band sought not just to entertain,
but to challenge, to prove that rock ‘n’ roll could be dangerous again.
They gravitated toward Andy Warhol — who brought Austrian
actress/model/chanteuse Nico into the fold — and became fixtures in
Warhol’s multimedia organization, the Factory, and in the Village
bohemian art scene.
Live, the Velvets were a bizarre amalgam
of vigorous R&B, pretty pop songs, extended experimental noise jams
and the performance art of Warhol’s Exploding Plastic Inevitable. The
original band lasted just two albums, “The Velvet Underground and
Nico,” and “White Light, White Heat” (both 1967), the first of which
stands among the greatest of all rock albums.
“Waiting for the Man,” with a breezy
rock groove, follows a Reed character in pursuit of drugs. Reed is
almost giddy with self-contempt as his need for drugs drags his social
status below that of ghetto dwellers, and that defiant self-contempt
defines the Velvet’s status as the first post-modern band and the
progenitor of the entire punk/new wave movement.
“Heroin” takes the external adventure of
obtaining drugs into the internal realm and captures the seduction of
addiction with a power, beauty and grace that makes it all the more
frightening. “Venus in Furs,” an unblinking examination of an S&M
relationship, conveys ennui of almost black hole density. “All
Tomorrow’’s Parties” is Nico’s finest moment, a towering aural monument
to ephemeral glamour, with the pulse of dread and Reed’s destabilizing
frantic guitar.
Also on the record are two more pretty,
Reed penned/Nico sung jewels, “I’ll Be Your Mirror” and “Femme Fatale,”
and the loveliest song of Reed’s career, the preternatural “Sunday
Morning,” which captures the hope and regret of a dawning Sunday with
awe and delicacy.
The group’s remaining three albums
produced several more gems in “White Light, White Heat,” “What Goes
On,” “Beginning to See the Light,” “Pale Blue Eyes,” “Sweet Jane,” and
“Rock and Roll,” all of which and more can be found in the highly
recommended box set “Peel Slowly and See.”
6. Led Zeppelin
Over a 10-year, nine-album career from 1969-79, Led
Zeppelin was the most popular rock group in the world, ultimately
selling more than 50 million records in the U.S. alone (more than 200
million worldwide), developing the blues-based power trio-plus-lead
singer archetype in many directions including mystical English
folk-rock, Middle Eastern-influenced exotica, quirky pop and every
manner of heaviness. They also came to symbolize the Dionysian excesses
of the rock lifestyle.
Their ubiquity on classic rock radio
formats and the aforementioned excesses have led many to dismiss the
band as overrated and symptomatic of the decline of rock ‘n’ roll in
the '70s. The super value collection “Early Days and Latter Days: Best
of Vols. 1 and 2” (two discs) prove that, if anything, the band’s musical
greatness is still underappreciated, due to the previously mentioned
resentments and the fact that the band had no greater cultural impact —
they didn’t much stand for anything.
 |
|
Murad Sezer / AP file
Led Zeppelin, with vocalist Robert
Plant, left, and guitarist Jimmy Page, came to symbolize the
Dionysian excesses of the rock lifestyle. The band, however, has sold
more than 50 million record in the U.S. alone.
|
Jimmy Page, who had led the last incarnation of the Yardbirds and had
been an extremely successful session guitarist (Who, Kinks, Them,
Donovan, Joe Cocker), formed the band in 1968 with veteran session
bassist/keyboardist John Paul Jones, 19-year-old singer Robert Plant
and Plant’s friend, drummer John Bonham. Commenting upon Page’s low
expectations for the success of the band, Keith Moon suggested the name
“Led Zeppelin.”
They were both wrong: “Led Zeppelin 1”
(“Good Times Bad Times,” “Babe, I’m Gonna Leave You,” “Dazed and
Confused,” “Communication Breakdown”), “Led Zeppelin 2” (“Whole
Lotta Love,” “The Lemon Song,” “Hearbreaker,” “Living Loving Maid,”
“Ramble On”) and “Led Zeppelin 4” (a.k.a. “Zoso,” with “Black Dog,”
“Rock and Roll,” “When the Levee Breaks,” “Stairway to Heaven”) are
among rock’s greatest albums.
Plant’s vocals reached levels of
deranged ecstasy matched perhaps only by Little Richard on lyrics
typically either oozing with sexuality or derived from Anglo-Saxon myth
and/or the occult. Bonham (whose accidental death in 1980 broke up the
band) pounded his drums relentlessly like a nimble elephant dancing
through the house. Jones’s bass and strategic keyboards glued the
disparate elements together. And Page, who did most of the writing and
production, played some of the most fundamental and memorable guitar in
rock history — from the heaviest crunch to the most delicate acoustic
finger picking.
Proving the band’s vast enduring
popularity, the band’s live two-DVD set “Led Zeppelin,” released last
May, has sold more than 600,000 copies.
7. Ramones
The Ramones — Dee Dee (bass, vocals), Joey (vocals),
Johnny (guitar), Tommy (drums, later replaced by Marky) — were the
American punk band, an endless wellspring of noise, energy, attitude,
humor and (sometimes forgotten) great songs, who helped reinvent rock
‘n’ roll when it needed it most in the mid-'70s.
Working for indie Sire Records in the
mid-'70s, producer/talent scout Craig Leon became involved with the
percolating New York underground music scene. One summer night in 1975
he went to CBGB’s and saw two bands, the Talking Heads and the Ramones.
“I went to that show and there were
literally four people in the audience besides me, but the bands were
phenomenal,” Leon said. “A lot of people didn’t even think the Ramones
could make a record. There were weeks of preproduction on a very basic
level: like when the songs started and when they ended. Their early
sets were one long song until they ran out of steam or fought. You
could see it as a performance art-type thing, where you had a 17-minute
concise capsule of everything you ever knew about rock ‘n’ roll, or you
could see it as 22 little songs,” he said. They went for the songs.
The Ramones’ first album (1976) is a
roaring minimalist icon — the first real American punk record. Layers
and layers of accumulated bloat and sheen were stripped away to reveal
rock ‘n’ roll at its most basic and vital on songs like “Blitzkreig
Bop,” “Beat On the Brat” and “Let’s Dance.” The Ramones’ sound was
blazing early-'60s surf music played through the overdriven distortion
of Blue Cheer and Black Sabbath. Yet, according to Leon, the Ramones
saw themselves as a pop band. “In our naivete, we thought they were
going to be bigger than the Beatles. They had even named themselves
after Paul McCartney’s early stage name, ‘Paul Ramone,’” Leon said.
While most agree the Ramones’
astonishing first album — which cut through the competition like a 747
in a paper airplane contest — is their most important album, it isn’t
my favorite. My favorite is one of the band’s most eccentric, “End of
the Century” — produced by the enigmatic pop icon (and now murder
suspect) Phil Spector — and the album that explicitly acknowledged such
a thing as “pop punk” for the first time.
Recorded in 1979, the album made
explicit the connection between early-'60s pop-rock and the punk band’s
psyche, and holds up as both a Ramones and a Spector classic —
Spector’s idiosyncrasies never overwhelm the roar of “Chinese Rock” or
“Rock ‘N’ Roll High School,” and the Spectorish “Do You Remember Rock
‘N’ Roll Radio” rollicks with just the right retro touches. The band’s
remake of the Ronette’s “Baby I Love You” is as touching as it is fun,
and shed a whole new light on singer Joey Ramone (who died in 2002
after a long bout with cancer — I sure do miss that guy).
The two-CD set “Hey! Ho! Let’s Go” is a
spectacular overview of the band, with all of the above songs (except
“Baby I Love You”) plus “California Sun,” “Sheena Is a Punk Rocker,”
“Cretin Hop,” “Rockaway Beach,” “Teenage Lobotomy,” “I Wanna Be
Sedated,” “She’s the One,” “She’s a Sensation,” “We Want the Airwaves”
and many, many more.
8. Pink Floyd
Pink Floyd is the most eccentric and experimental
multi-platinum band of the album rock era, creating exceptional
cinematic sound sculptures “Meddle,” “Dark Side of the Moon,” “Wish You
Were Here,” and the band’s popular apex and conceptual death knell,
“The Wall.”
Beginning in the mid-'60s as a
R&B-based hard rock band, the band (named after Piedmont blues men
Pink Anderson and Floyd Council) — Syd Barrett on guitar and vocals,
Roger Waters on bass and vocals, Richard Wright on keyboards, and Nick
Mason on drums — mutated quickly into a strange combination of twee
British psychedelia (“See Emily Play,” “Arnold Layne”) and long-form
instrumental space rock (“Astronomy Domine,” “Interstellar Overdrive”),
inspired by Barrett’s liberal LSD use: a Cambridge English garden
transported to Mars.
Guitarist David Gilmour joined the group
as insurance against Barrett’s volatility in '68, but when Barrett was
forced out for unreliability his “backup band” became a democratic
foursome sharing writing, singing and leadership duties. As Floyd
headed more deeply into experimental symphonic explorations in the
sonic chill of space — about as far removed from rock ‘n’ roll’s
origins in amped-up American teenage hormones as possible — the more
popular they became.
“Meddle,” released in 1971, was the
band’s transition album from the Barrett-influenced '60s to the
Waters-Gilmour Floyd of the 1970s, highlighted by a pillar of space
rock greatness “Echoes,” over 23 minutes of confidently creative
meandering, ingratiating harmony vocals from Waters and Gilmour,
burbling organ from Wright, atmospheric axemanship from the
incomparable Gilmour, otherworldly pings and drifting whale noises. You
can hear the fertile seeds of “Dark Side of the Moon” here.
“Dark Side,” released in '73, stayed on
the album chart for an outrageous 741 weeks, a masterpiece of creative
studio craft and a remarkably unified exploration of time, greed and
existence — the album is an indispensable rite of passage still. “Wish
You Were Here” is an exceptional, ruminative, ambient, long-form look
at the disintegration of Barrett intermingled with Roger Waters’
souring view of the world, and in particular, the music industry.
That dim view of life found its ultimate
expression in “The Wall,” which used its title to represent literal and
metaphoric isolation. In elaborate theatrical presentations of the
work, a wall was physically constructed throughout the performance, the
collapse of which at the end of each show neatly presaged the group’s
fate. Waters went solo in the early-'80s and the group has reunited
periodically without him, but neither the group nor he have ever been
the same since.
9. Bob Marley and the Wailers
The greatest singer, songwriter, and cultural figure
in Jamaican history, Bob Marley brought the righteous message and
“positive vibrations” of reggae music to the world, and is the only
towering figure of the rock era not from America or the U.K.
 |
|
AP file
Jamaican singer Bob Marley brought the
righteous message and “positive vibrations” of reggae music to the
world.
|
Marley and his band, the Wailers, created transcendent music around the
entrancing, inverted reggae beat and unforgettable melodies that
equally decried poverty and injustice and celebrated physical and
spiritual ecstasy — all of it grounded in Marley’s abiding Rastafarian
faith. Marley’s influence is so pervasive, his music so seductive, and
respect for him so great throughout the world that it is easy to forget
the beliefs and customs of the Rastas are rather, in a word, odd:
reverence of Emperor Haile Selassie I of Ethiopia as a living god who
would lead the oppressed black diaspora back to an African homeland
(rather more difficult after he died in 1975), smoking the holy herb of
enlightenment, ganja (marijuana), as daily sacrament, growing their
hair in dreadlocks.
Marley was born in rural St. Ann’s
Parish in 1945 to a middle-aged white father and a teen-aged black
mother, and left home for the tough Trench Town slum of Kingston at 14
in order to pursue a life in music. There he became friends, and formed
a vocal trio, with Peter Tosh and Bunny Wailer. They called themselves
the Wailing Wailers, later shortened to the Wailers. They worked within
the prevailing musical styles of the time, first the buoyant up-tempo
ska, then the slower sinuous rock steady, which then gave way to reggae.
The Wailers recorded with legendary
producers Coxone Dodd and Lee “Scratch” Perry in the '60s, recording
great songs like “Simmer Down,” the original version of “One Love,”
“Soul Rebel,” “Small Axe” and “Duppy Conqueror,” becoming greatly
popular in Jamaica. But it was when the Wailers signed with Chris
Blackwell’s Island Records in 1972 that their reach became global.
The Wailers' first albums for Island,
“Catch a Fire” and “Burnin’” (both '73), became instant classics and
introduced “Stir it Up,” “I Shot the Sheriff,” and Tosh’s “Get Up Stand
Up” to the world. Tosh and Wailer then both left to pursue solo careers
and the Wailers became Marley’s vehicle of expression. Until his tragic
death from cancer at the age of 36 in 1981, Marley generated anthem
after anthem and brought hope and pride to the Third World, in addition
to touching hearts and moving feet across North America and Europe.
His hits collection covering the Island
years, “Legend,” with sales of over 10 million copies in the U.S.
alone, is the most popular and enduring reggae album of all time. Among
its delights are “No Woman No Cry,” “Three Little Birds,” “One Love,”
“Buffalo Soldier,” “Waiting In Vain” and “Jamming.”
10. Sly and the Family Stone
Sly and the Family Stone made some of the most buoyant and thoughtful
music of the late-'60s and early-'70s, uniting and transforming black
and white music at a time of highest hope and deepest betrayal in
America. Leader Sly Stone personified both extremes, as the truest of
believers and a victim of his own disillusionment.
Stone was a musical child prodigy who recorded a gospel song at age
four. In the mid-'60s he produced hit records for the Beau Brummels and
Bobby Freeman before his dream blossomed into the colorful, freaky Sly
and the Family Stone. Sly wrote the songs, created the arrangements and
handled the production, but allowed each member to express his/her
individual identity. The Family blended blacks and whites, men and
women: Sly’s brother Freddie Stewart on electric guitar, sister Rose on
electric piano, Sly’s high school friends Cynthia Robinson on trumpet
and Jerry Martini on sax, Martini’s cousin Gregg Errico on drums, and
thumping, popping funk bass pioneer Larry Graham.
It was on the band’s second LP, “Dance
To The Music” ('68) that they really caught fire. The title song was a
perfect representation of the live Family sound, a vibrant amalgam of
positivity, fuzz bass, doo-wop, rock guitar and horns, gathered in the
context of a traditional R&B revue.
The summer of '69 found Sly and the
Family Stone rising to the heights of popularity and critical acclaim
on the wings of their phenomenal album “Stand!,” which included the
band’s first No. 1 hit, “Everyday People,” a song that defined
the band’s social ideals in the way that “Dance” defined its musical
thoughts. The charm of the nursery rhyme refrain cuts through centuries
of cultural bias and reminds us of the simple truth that “we got to
live together” or die separately. Also on the album was the orgasmic “I
Want to Take You Higher.”
That same summer, Sly and Family Stone
stormed the stage at Woodstock in rainbow get-ups, flashing of sequins
and electricity and came away superstars. If the attendees weren’t high
enough, when Sly cried out “I Want to Take You Higher” at the end of
the band’s set, many feel the festival — and an era — reached their
frenzied peak.
Unfortunately, Sly took his obsession
with “highness” literally and came to confuse the easy high of drugs
with the more difficult highs of music, love and the joy of existence.
With the drugs came increasing paranoia and self-absorption that were
expressed first and best on 1971’s “There’s A Riot Goin’ On,” where
lassitude replaced spunk but Sly’s incredible talent still shined
through the murk. Drummer Errico left during the production and Sly
further damaged the family feel by playing most of the instruments on
the album himself, isolated in a cocaine cocoon. Ironically, “Riot” was
the “band’s” only No. 1 album. The dream and the reality then both fell
apart, but the music remains.
How? Why?
While I speak with the thunderous voice of truth,
this list of “the 10 best rock bands ever” isn’t a purely
arbitrary designation yanked from my nether regions. First, the winners
had to be an actual band, which eliminated most of the first wave rock
‘n’ roll greats of the '50s like Elvis and Chuck Berry, who were
essentially solo artists with backup bands, other towering figures like
Bob Dylan, and vocal groups. The bands had to be within the greater
circle of “rock” music and generate most or all of their own material.
I took into account musical and cultural influence, popularity over
time (staying power), and the “It’s a Wonderful Life” factor: What
damage would be done if the band were to be removed from rock history?
— the greater the damage, the greater the band. Removal of any of the
above 10 would render rock history unrecognizable.
Eric Olsen is the editor of Blogcritics.org
and a regular contributor to MSNBC.com.
Note from Webmaster::"I did'nt write this piece .but read it on MSN and found it intresting..and wanted to share with you.if the authur of this piece ..objects to it being here..please feel free to email me EMAIL
and i'll remove it right away...and thank you MSN for running it,,great place to go for music information."